Chat with us, powered by LiveChat

Five Point Cottage

Five Point Cottage at Old Town
3 Bedrooms 3 Bathrooms House in Niagara on the lake
from $305 per /nt
from $2700 per /wk

Five Point Cottage

Located in the historic Chautauqua area of Old Town. This property is steps to Lake Ontario and a lovely walk along the lake to the fantastic dining and shopping area of Niagara on the Lake and is perfect for family get together. The home sleeps 10.

Availability & Booking Calendar

Property Description

Located in the historic Chautauqua area of Old Town. This property is steps to Lake Ontario and a lovely walk along the lake to the fantastic dining and shopping area of Niagara on the Lake and is perfect for family get together. The home sleeps 10.

Property Details

This delightful home offers 2800 square feet of living space. A master bedroom with ensuite, 3 queen bedrooms, and a bedroom with 2 twin beds, suitable for 10 people to stay. Located in the historic Chautauqua area, it is a stroll away from the lake and only a small distance from the main street. A short drive takes you to the weekend farmer's market, craft breweries, and wineries.


The name of the street it is on, Shakespeare Avenue is of course named after the great playwright. In fact, the streets that would have encircled the amphitheater that was there for the Chautauqua lessons/shows were all named after literary icons and philosophers, such as Wilberforce and Wesley.


The main floor offers a foyer leading to a large living room where friends and family can gather, sit, and relax, with a fireplace for those cooler nights. The living room flows into a chef style kitchen for all your cooking needs and a dining area. On the main floor are 3 bedrooms. A master bedroom with a King size bed and en-suite, a second bedroom with a Queen bed, a third bedroom with a Queen bed. On the lower level is a spacious area to sit and relax, playing board games or watching tv, perfect for rainy days. On the lower level are 2 twin beds and another with an additional Queen bed with the third bathroom. All of the bedrooms are fitted with luxurious linens and bedding that will be sure to provide a good night rest.

Enjoy an evening glass of local wine among family in the private backyard surrounded by oak trees and situated on a wooded area where deer and wild turkeys are often visible. The back garden is complete with a large deck and a flagstone patio and a lovely sitting area for ten and equipped with a gas BBQ. Stroll down to the lake and enjoy one of the best sunsets according to National Geographic Magazine.

Five Point Cottage offers an entire home for you and your guests to get away from it all, yet feel right at home!

Your hosts will greet you at the property and show you the workings of the home. In the unlikely event, there is anything needed during your stay, we are just a phone call away!

Guest Access:
Full home, free wifi, patio, BBQ, free on-site parking
We will greet you at the home, and show you around.
Niagara-on-the-Lake is the ideal travel destination year-round! Offering an abundance of attractions: the Shaw Festival Theater, expansive recreation trail, art galleries, Whirlpool Jet Boats, world class dining, Fort George, award winning wineries/winery tasting & tours and festivals throughout the year including the Niagara Ice Wine Festival, and the Peach festival. Niagara on the Lake provides something for everyone.
This property has 1 King(s), 1 Queen(s), 1 Queen(s), 1 Queen(s), 2 Twin(s).
  • Bedrooms











    $305 - $595


  • Stove
  • Dishes & Utensils
  • Linens Provided
  • Health Beauty Spa
  • Museums
  • Winery Tours
  • Outlet Shopping
  • Dining Area
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Duty Free
  • Toaster
  • Living Room
  • Smoke Detector
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Fire Extinguisher
  • Hair Dryer
  • Satellite / Cable
  • Air Conditioning
  • Central Heat
  • Coffee Maker
  • Cookware
  • Television
  • Iron and Board
  • Kitchen
  • Parking
  • Shopping
  • Towels Provided
  • Internet - Wireless
  • Parks
  • Dining Room
  • Game Room
  • Gas Grill
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Deck/Patio
  • Dishwasher
  • Fireplace
  • Garage
  • Heating
  • Microwave
  • Washing Machine

Guest Reviews

Beautiful place and very spacious! by Jessica 10/21/2019
Beautiful place and very spacious! We really enjoyed our stay. Thank you!
A lovely property on an enchanting street in NOTL. by Amorosa 10/15/2019
A lovely property on an enchanting street in NOTL. Immaculately clean, spacious yet cozy, exactly as advertised. I first stayed at Five Points Cottage in August 2018 with a group of girlfriends (7 in total) celebrating a 50th birthday. I knew immediately that it would be a great get-away place for my own multi-generational family of 10, including my parents, siblings & their children. We chose Five Points for our Family Thanksgiving Weekend this year and were not disappointed. Everyone loved it! It was an added bonus to be able to bring our family pup! The cottage is well laid out and tastefully decorated. Being a bungalow, with bedrooms on the main floor, it meant that my elderly parents did not have to negotiate stairs, which was very convenient. The place is well-stocked, with lovely, homey little touches (throw blankets, books and board games) and almost every kitchen appliance and utensil you could think of or need. Very helpful for preparing a Thanksgiving dinner for 10. All we had to do was bring the food! We had a slight issue with the hot water heater (no hot water) when we arrived, but a quick call to Mark and he sent someone over to rectify the problem straight away. And on a holiday weekend, no less! We are grateful that it was handled so efficiently. Sincerest thanks to Mark and NOTL Vacation Rentals for another wonderful stay! 4.5 stars
Good experience by Zelda 10/06/2019
Overall satisfied. Recommend putting extr blankets in closets available - not a single extra blanket to be used. Also would be nice to have a few more comfortable arm chairs in the lounge for large groups.
Great location; very well maintained home. by Lorraine 09/30/2019
Great location; very well maintained home. Perfect for our ladies getaway weekend.
Very spacious, well organized and extremely well equipped. by Ognjen 09/26/2019
My book club friends and I celebrated 15th anniversary at the house and had a great time. There were eight of us , but the house sleeps 10 comfortably. The place is super clean and comfortable. Very spacious, well organized and extremely well equipped. Location is great - minutes to the lake and nice walk to the town. We will come again.
Excellent backyard by Ryan 08/06/2019
Awesome house for our group of 7. Extremely spacious and well furnished w/ an excellent backyard
Better than we expected by Amy 07/10/2019
The house was better than we expected from the online listing. It was well equipped and very, very clean. The lower level is huge - two bedrooms, a dressing room, a bathroom, ​and a giant family room. Best of all, the house is only a short walk from a park on Lake Ontario with swimming access. We will definitely book again next time we are in Niagara-on-the Lake!
Clean and great location by Pat 07/06/2019
This is a lovely cottage in a great location for walking and exploring the area.
Peaceful upscale neighborhood by Jerry 07/02/2019
5 Points Cottage is a lovely home in a peaceful upscale neighborhood. Dealing with Mark was easy and efficient and the property was perfect for our needs.
Beautiful house by Lia 06/19/2019
It was a beautiful house with lots of room for the 9 of us. All the bedrooms were nice- 3 upstairs and 2 downstairs.
They had nothing but great things to say about their stay. by Jessica 06/02/2019
I booked this house for my mom and her sisters for a girls weekend. They all raved about the place and how perfect it was for them. They appreciated all the bathrooms and only a few had to share beds. There was plenty room for everyone. They loved being about to walk around the beautiful area and down to the water. They had nothing but great things to say about their stay.
Perfect space by Julia 05/28/2019
Perfect space for our group, and great location for wine touring! Felt very welcome and the ​house was better than expected! Highly recommend.
Location was great! Photos are true to life! Would rent again by Elaine 09/15/2018
We had a party of 9 for Niagara Wine Festival. Location was great, convenient to town and wineries, very quiet with off street parking a bonus. Comfortable beds and fully equipped kitchen. Photos are true to life. Outdoor deck and patio great for evening wine and cheese and morning coffee. Short walk to small park to watch sailboats on the lake and green space in the back yard. Management company provided personal recommendations for dining.
Clean and professionally managed! by Karen, Boston Ma 09/08/2018
Lovely comfortable clean welcoming. Professionally overseen. Beds particularly comfortable. Outdoor garden inviting. Actually a 6 minute drive. We had a car and so it didn't matter. Very residential neighborhood, totally unlike town district. I would rent it again and again.
Great place-well furnished-great location by Judith 09/04/2018
Great place---well furnished--great location
My friends and I had a wonderful time in NOTL and our accommodations were perfect! The house was well cared for and in a great location close to the lake and the town. There was plenty of room for all of us . I would stay there again!
Girls Weekend winery hopping! by Wendy B. 08/23/2018
Review #23451442 Girls Weekend winery hopping!
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Just returned from a long weekend stay at the Five Point Cottage! High school friends girl weekend! This cottage is so spacious and nicely decorated. The inside was very clean and organized. Lots of room! Beds all had comfortable mattresses. Would recommend this property. I would only suggest maybe making sure the smaller back patio off the side of the house is cleaned and ready for use, it was really dirty and disorganized. Ideal location to historic town, waterfront, and wineries! We plan to return in the future!
I would recommend this cottage to any of my family or friends! by Wendy 08/21/2018
Just returned from our stay at this beautiful property. I visited NOTL for a girls weekend with friends from high school. This cottage is one of the nicest properties I have rented through HomeAway. The home was so clean. The home is decorated so beautiful. Each bedroom is unique in décor. The beds were so comfortable! The home is spacious! Loved the open plan for the kitchen/dining and living room! We hung out there quite a bit sipping wine we had bought, drinking coffee, watching movies and playing charades! The home is located close to town and it is within walking distance to the water. I would recommend this cottage to any of my family or friends! Would love to return their again in the future! Thanks to NOTL Vacation Rentals - Cody met us at the house and gave us an informative tour of the home and explained everything for us!
Ideal location by Brenda and Paul 08/04/2018
Ideal location, excellent accommodation, extremely well equipped home, very comfortable, wonderful neighborhood close to downtown but far enough away to be quiet in the evenings.
Great place to come by Rose J. 08/02/2018
Review #23002200 Great place to come ★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Amazing house to have a social get together and not feel crowded. The place was clean and equipped with everything you need. A fantastic experience overall.
Very clean and Spacious by Shirly 07/29/2018
Review #22999558 10/10 would go again
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
It was very clean, looked exactly like the pictures, very spacious and was close to all the main attractions.

Date of arrival
July 20, 2018
Wonderful, comfortable, clean home! by Joan 07/22/2018
Review #22849881 “Five Point Exlusive Cottage Sleeps up to 10 with 3 bathrooms”

Wonderful, comfortable, clean home!
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
We had a wonderful time staying here. It is just as it appears on the website. The rooms are very clean and tastefully decorated. The beds were clean and extremely comfortable. The kitchen had everything we needed. The location was ideal. It was a five minute walk down a lovely, quiet street to a beautiful little park where we witnessed some beautiful sunsets. The home is in a quiet neighborhood and only a 3 minute drive to the main street in town. Everything was ready for us when we arrived and we couldn't have been happier with our stay. Despite pictures there is always some level of risk when renting a home you have not seen but not the case here. It is a lovely home and we would definitely come back again.
Beautiful home, huge 5 stars by Rachel 07/09/2018
Beautiful place, huge, walking distance to downtown area - 5 stars!!!!
Wonderful Vacation, accommodating, happy with stay. by Jennifer 07/06/2018
The five point Cottage at Niagara on the lake was perfect for my family eight adults and one-year-old. It was a quick walk to the beach and not far from downtown. Making it easy for us to get around. The house was clean, and spacious for our family. Mark was very helpful and kept it simple getting us set up and leaving us great instructions. The backyard was great for our morning coffee, and our evening barbecue.
Very clean and lovely cottage. by Kevin 10/28/2017
Review #20359633 Very clean and lovely cottage.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
We arrived early and had access to the house which enhanced our stay. Comfortable accommodations with king master suite and 2 bedrooms with queen. Lovely well stocked kitchen. Could have easily cooked a great dinner but we chose to go out. Outdoor spaces were very comfortable as well. Good Time,
Date of arrival
October 13, 2017
Great stay, good location by Debbie 10/03/2017
Review #19726484 Great stay, good location,
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Property was well maintained, clean and roomy. Location was great. Enjoyed a great weekend here with friends

Date of arrival
September 29, 2017
The weekend was amazing and the cottage was a big part of that experience! by Ash 09/06/2017
Great back yard with a BBQ. Also, the cottage is spacious, well stocked, clean, and had everything you'd need for an awesome weekend in Niagara.
Excellent choice for your stay in NOTL by Chris 08/10/2017
Review #18806173 Excellent choice for your stay in NOTL
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Spacious and nicely furnished home and very close to everything in NOTL. Mark was responsive and great to work with. There's an awesome public park on Lake Ontario right at the end of the street! Would definitely book again.

Reviewer location
Denver, Colorado
Date of arrival
August 4, 2017
Lovely by Ladies Weekened 08/04/2017
Review #18659251 Ladies Weekend
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Our group of seven women rented Five Point Cottage to celebrate a coworker's retirement. We loved the spaciousness of the cottage, especially having the bedrooms and three baths. The location was convenient to wineries, Lake Ontario sunsets, shopping and shuttles to the Falls. Its well-equipped kitchen and laundry meant that we could arrive and focus solely on relaxation and entertainment. Lovely areas for enjoying meals and drinks outdoors.

Date of arrival
Great location! Great house just to relax by Sandy 07/13/2017
Review #18155465 Great location! Great house just to relax.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
This house was beautiful, both inside and out. While there were only two couples there, it had plenty of room if you wanted to have more people. And, the basement would have worked out very well kids' sleeping/play area. The kitchen was well stocked with utensils, cookware, and tableware to cook and serve meals. It was close to town, and while we did not make that walk, it was extremely doable. There is a great outdoor area where we enjoyed our morning coffee and afternoon/evening adult beverages. And the neighborhood is very quiet. From the house you can walk, with your adult beverage glass, to the lake and watch some of the most remarkable sunsets. Mark was extremely responsive and fun when we had questions (and we had a lot because that is how we roll). Recommend this highly and would definitely stay there again.

Date of arrival
July 3, 2017
Thanks Mark - beautiful place, great location, well-stocked kitchen. Clean! by Audra D 07/05/2017
We spent the holiday weekend at Mark's place in NOTL. The location is great - away from the large crowds but easy to walk to the center of town (a beautiful walk!). The house itself is fantastic. The photos seriously don't do it justice. So clean, well stocked kitchen, easy to find, and Mark is very available if needed. The backyard is very cozy and was a great space to relax. VERY comfortable beds. Overall, a fantastic rental.
Quaint and private by Janet T 06/19/2017
Review #17860007

Quaint and private
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Our family gathers once a year on Fathers Day to honour a special man (husband, brother, father) We bring lots of food, wine and board games...we take walks and soak in the spectacular sunsets...this 'cottage' was the perfect size and space for us, with a well-equipped kitchen, luxury bedding, pillow soft sleeps, comfy, private patio, perfect for BBQing...Mark was helpful and welcoming...I took lots of photos to remember this special weekend years down the road...thank you!

Date of arrival
June 16, 2017
Clean & Serene! by John 06/15/2017
Review #17702502 “Five Point Cottage Located in Historic Old Town Niagara-on-the-Lake”

Clean & Serene!
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Lovely with spacious rooms, elegantly decorated.

Date of arrival
June 2, 2017
Great House by Ed 05/27/2017
Mark was a terrific host. He met us as planned, walked us through the house, and provided tips for seeing the area. We couldn't have asked for better. The cottage was as described - beautiful, large, comfortable and ready for guests. It was a short drive to the downtown area where the theaters are located. Easily walkable. We loved NOTL, and if we were to return for another visit (seems likely), we would plan on using this home again. Very satisfied.view
Great location by Diane O 10/27/2016
Five point cottage worked out great for our girls weekend. The location is close to Niagara on the Lake and half an hour to Niagara Falls. The house was clean and in great shape. All the beds were comfy.
Spacious by Bobbie Jo L 10/14/2016
It was a great house! We had a little surprise gathering for my moms birthday and the house worked perfectly. There is a lot of room, the bedrooms were spacious, well decorated, and well maintained. No issues and over all a great weekend. The lake is about a 3 min walk and not to far from downtown.
Location and very nice accommodations by Nav 09/25/2016
Ideal location! Close to downtown, shops, theaters, and golf course. So happy to arrive to see beautiful home--very modern, clean, and accommodating! Enjoyed our getaway weekend here at Niagara on the Lake. Mark met us and gave us many good tips and suggestions for shopping and restaurants to make our trip full of fun. Thoroughly enjoyed our weekend!
Best looking house on the block by Ash 09/01/2016
Everything was clean and neat. The house is easily the best looking one on the block, and the lawn and property is well maintained. Not sure if the listing mentioned it, but there's also a kick ass backyard with BBQ, chairs, table and umbrella. This was ideal for dinner after we went wine tasting all day.
Mark communicated with us throughout our trip (both by message as well as through detailed instructions at the house), which allowed us to know exactly what was expected of us as well as how we could access the amenities etc.
Ideal location by Brenda 09/01/2016
Ideal location! Close to downtown, shops, theaters, and golf course. So happy to arrive to see beautiful home--very modern, clean, and accommodating! Enjoyed our getaway weekend here at Niagara on the Lake.
Mark met us and gave us many good tips and suggestions for shopping and restaurants to make our trip full of fun.
Thoroughly enjoyed our weekend!
Spacious and well equipped by David 08/01/2016
Mark overseas several homes and knows his stuff! He was very responsive and available. The house was spacious and well equipped. Lots of room inside, as well as great outdoor "hang" space (and a BBQ).


Daily Rate: $305 - $595 per night
Weekly Rate: $2700 per week
- Rate varies due to seasonality and holidays.
- Please select your dates on our online booking calendar for an exact quote.


Standard Tax Rate - 13.00%
Pet Fee - $75.00
Five Point Cottage Cleaning - $150.00
Security Deposit - $500.00
Cancellation Policy
Cancellations are subject up to a 50% cancellation fee and must be confirmed through email. If less than 60 days prior to your arrival, the full amount will be forfeited.
Please notify us immediately if you cannot use your reservation. If successful in finding a suitable replacement booking for the dates of your reservation, at our discretion we will refund the payment less administration fees determined at the time the replacement booking is confirmed and paid for.
Last updated 02/17/2020
Deposit Policy
Direct bookings through 100% payment is due at the time of booking by credit card (MasterCard, Visa or Amex)
Last updated 02/17/2020

Property Location